Alberta Teachers Feel Isolated as Many Seek Jobs Outside Province

School-related graphics on blacktop.

Feeling isolated and unsupported, Jesica Torres is on the lookout for a teaching role outside of Alberta.

After participating in a strike aimed at improving classroom conditions, she had hoped to receive encouragement from the community.

“Following the strike, I imagined walking into my classroom to see all my students dressed in red,” recalled the Grade 5 teacher from Calgary, referencing the color that represented solidarity among educators during the lengthy strike last fall. “But only two were.”

“It feels as if we are all on our own,” she expressed.

“I don’t sense that people acknowledge the difficulties we are facing or appreciate how much effort I put in for the children of Alberta. It’s disheartening.”

  • What has your experience been like in Alberta schools? Whether you are a teacher, parent, or student, we are eager to hear your story. Please email us at ask@cbc.ca.
  • Read our Inside the Classroom series at cbc.ca/inside.

An unusual mass email initiative

Torres was among over 6,000 educators, principals, and staff who shared their insights with CBC News following a mass email and questionnaire sent to 23,000 educators in Alberta in January.

More than 5,000 respondents indicated they were feeling discouraged, believing that conditions in the province’s schools are unlikely to improve anytime soon, despite the sacrifices made during the strike and assurances from political leaders afterward.

WATCH | A check-in with teachers three months post-strike:

How are Alberta teachers feeling three months after striking?

February 5|

Duration

1:19

Only 126 participants reported feeling optimistic.

Additionally, when asked another question, 30% indicated they were trying to leave the profession—actively searching for opportunities outside of teaching or considering early retirement.

The provincial administration has since committed to a seven-percent increase in the education budget, but it remains uncertain if this will suffice to boost morale.

Torres mentioned that she has already completed her certification application to teach in British Columbia and just needs to settle the fee.

“I’m a fourth-generation Albertan,” she shared. “Part of me wants to persevere. [However], when you return home feeling like you’ve let your students down daily, it becomes morally draining.”

Exploring the complexities of school dynamics

In January, CBC News took the uncommon initiative of contacting teachers directly due to the extraordinary labor situation and their claims about the challenges students face in Alberta’s classrooms.

We inquired about their well-being, whether they still endorse the movement for smaller class sizes, and their perspectives on inclusion policies (integrating students with complex needs into neighborhood schools).

We also asked them what topics they would cover if they were journalists for a week, revealing a growing mistrust between some parents and educators, ineffective discipline strategies in certain schools, and the challenges posed by students with significant medical or behavioral requirements, along with a new elementary curriculum introduced with minimal resources.

A significant amount of frustration was expressed—much directed at the government, some towards union leaders, and in a few instances, at school district officials.

Honestly, I feel totally hopeless.A high school teacher in the Calgary region

We will continue to explore the insights these responses generated.

The questionnaire served as a listening exercise aimed at reaching as many educators and school staff as possible. It is not a scientifically validated random sample and was not restricted by a password for educators only. We do not interpret the findings as having statistical validity.

However, with over 6,000 responses, it provides a glimpse into Alberta’s educational landscape and serves as a foundation for further exploration.

Children work at their desks in a classroom.

Educators report that being aware of students’ needs yet being unable to assist everyone is demoralizing. (CBC News)

The most significant revelation was the extent of the demoralization among many teachers.

When we asked: how do you currently feel about your role in the educational environment? About 400 teachers and principals indicated their sentiments had not changed, but many others shared comments like:

  • “Honestly, I feel totally hopeless. We are so disrespected by this government.”
  • “The public education system in Alberta is collapsing.”
  • “I’m currently on stress leave, so I would describe my current feelings as overwhelmed and exhausted.”
  • “I am glad to be back teaching my students, as I believe the students are the biggest victims in this whole situation. However, I am contemplating transitioning from a full-time teaching role to either substitute teaching or pursuing a career outside of education entirely.”

Some expressed feelings of inadequacy due to the overwhelming demands placed upon them. This encompasses not just the number of students they must instruct but also the fact that numerous students require individualized teaching plans—sometimes necessitating entirely different lesson plans for those who are several grades behind their peers.

Many teachers and principals are concerned about an impending staffing crisis as colleagues exit the profession.

Last fall, 51,000 educators across Alberta participated in a strike lasting over three weeks, from October 6 to 29. These educators demanded limitations on classroom size and complexity, along with a pay raise. The strike concluded when the UCP government enforced a contract and invoked the notwithstanding clause.

The provincial government also committed to hiring more teachers, established a cabinet committee tasked with tackling issues within Alberta’s public education system, and began gathering data on classroom complexity.

Clinging to optimism

While the overwhelming majority of educators who responded to our survey expressed negativity, a handful conveyed a sense of hope for change.

Marni Kondor, a Grade 4 teacher in Edmonton, manages a class of 26 students, about 30% of whom are newcomers to Canada and still acquiring English skills. The class presents numerous learning challenges and is among the most complex she has encountered.

However, she has adapted her expectations—she no longer focuses on teaching newcomer students about Alberta’s democratic principles, as suggested by the curriculum, but is content to help them grasp the English language first.

Additionally, her colleagues provide each other with morale boosts during lunch breaks.

In a conversation with CBC News following her questionnaire submission, Kondor described herself as inherently hopeful. She recalled a recent interview with Premier Danielle Smith discussing the influx of newcomer students, which left her feeling encouraged.

“She is aware of the challenges surrounding the [English language learner] situation. She acknowledges it and spoke about it herself,” she stated. “That’s why I thought, ‘Maybe they are close to developing a system where these new arrivals don’t go straight into a mainstream classroom.’ They could receive support to learn the language for a few months first.”

She is choosing to give Smith a chance and believes the government is seeking solutions.

A man stands in front of a white board with his arms crossed.

Graham Langridge, a high school math teacher in Red Deer, admits he still feels affected by the fall strike. (Submitted by Graham Langridge)

Conversely, Graham Langridge, a math teacher at a Red Deer high school, shared that he continues to feel the emotional impact of the strike and struggles to envision how educators and schools might recover from these challenges.

“I experience a deep sense of despair,” he remarked. “Despite my hard work, I often feel a knot in my stomach. [This situation] has fundamentally shaken my trust in the institution.”

Langridge co-hosts a podcast titled Harmonious Gentlemen, aiming to promote constructive discussions about contentious topics. He appreciates that the strike allowed him to engage in “productive conversations with skeptical peers” regarding the evolution of schools.

However, regarding the provincial government, he has reached out to his MLA multiple times and invited him on the podcast, yet without success. He expresses skepticism when hearing about new government initiatives, such as gathering data on classroom complexity, and points out that a seven-percent funding increase still leaves Alberta trailing behind the national average in educational funding.

“Can they genuinely recruit and retain that many teachers in a province that has shown indifference toward educators? How much of this will actually benefit our public schools, where the demand is immense?” he asked.

“I find it extremely difficult to believe that this government genuinely cares for public education. I hope they prove me wrong.”


What are your thoughts on our reporting about Alberta schools? What topics would you like us to cover next? Please reach out via email toask@cbc.ca.

Latest

Trump, Xi, and Putin Meet for Historic Nuclear Dialogue in Shenzhen

On Thursday, U.S. President Donald Trump held an extraordinary...

Geneticists Use Drones to Map Whale Genes from Mucus Clouds

Quirks and Quarks54:00Flying drones through whale snotThis week's edition...

Quebec Environmental Group Sues to Reverse Emissions Deadline Extension

A Quebec-based environmental legal organization, along with eight citizens,...

Maple Leafs Shake Up Front Office Amid Major Team Restructuring

Further modifications have occurred within the front office of...

Don't miss

Trump, Xi, and Putin Meet for Historic Nuclear Dialogue in Shenzhen

On Thursday, U.S. President Donald Trump held an extraordinary...

Geneticists Use Drones to Map Whale Genes from Mucus Clouds

Quirks and Quarks54:00Flying drones through whale snotThis week's edition...

Quebec Environmental Group Sues to Reverse Emissions Deadline Extension

A Quebec-based environmental legal organization, along with eight citizens,...

Maple Leafs Shake Up Front Office Amid Major Team Restructuring

Further modifications have occurred within the front office of...

Ottawa Couple’s Joint Murder Trial for Infant Begins in Court

WARNING: This article includes information about violence involving children.The...

Trump, Xi, and Putin Meet for Historic Nuclear Dialogue in Shenzhen

On Thursday, U.S. President Donald Trump held an extraordinary three-way meeting with his Chinese and Russian counterparts, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, concluding their...

Geneticists Use Drones to Map Whale Genes from Mucus Clouds

Quirks and Quarks54:00Flying drones through whale snotThis week's edition of Quirks & Quarks hosted by Bob McDonald features:The reason geneticists deployed a drone into...

Quebec Environmental Group Sues to Reverse Emissions Deadline Extension

A Quebec-based environmental legal organization, along with eight citizens, is suing the provincial government over its choice to postpone a greenhouse gas emissions reduction...