WARNING: This article includes information about violence involving children.
The joint trial for a couple from Ottawa charged with the murder of a seven-week-old infant commenced on Tuesday at the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.
Boravy Buth, the child’s mother, alongside Patrick O’Connor, faces charges of second-degree murder. Additionally, Buth is charged with criminal negligence resulting in death. Both individuals are not in custody and were present in the public seating area as the trial began with the Crown’s opening statements.
Both Buth and O’Connor have entered pleas of not guilty. A jury of 12 will determine the outcome of their case.
Crown attorney Sonia Beauchamp contended that both defendants are culpable, asserting that the baby was assaulted on the day of his death, October 26, 2021.
At approximately 4:30 a.m. that day, authorities received a call regarding an infant who was not breathing at a residence in Ottawa’s western area.
Beauchamp mentioned that when the two initial officers arrived at the scene, they did not obtain any details from the couple about the incident until the mother was directly questioned.
Originally, Buth and O’Connor faced charges in 2023 for failing to provide the necessities of life, following a 16-month investigation conducted by the police homicide unit along with the units for sexual assault and child abuse. Their charges were subsequently elevated.

An undated archival image of the Ottawa Courthouse. (Deborah MacAskill/CBC )
Crown presents initial witnesses
The first witness for the Crown, Const. Stefan Kubiseski, was among the officers sent to the scene early that autumn morning more than four years ago.
Kubiseski testified that he and his partner, Const. Jordan Blonde, arrived shortly after receiving the call and immediately attempted CPR on the infant.
As he held the baby’s head, Kubiseski noted bruising on the infant’s right eyelid and extending from his left shoulder down to his neck. He also observed a change in the baby’s skin color from pink to dark purple as the officers administered CPR.
Upon the arrival of paramedics, Kubiseski stated they took over and began chest compressions on the baby. Soon afterward, they transported the child in an ambulance to the hospital.
Following this, Kubiseski returned inside the home, where he spoke with Buth to gather information for the paramedics and medical personnel.
Kubiseski reported that Buth claimed the baby fell off a bed between 2:00 a.m. and 2:30 a.m. She stated she carried him around the room before returning him to bed once he seemed fine. At about 4:15 a.m., she recounted being awakened by O’Connor, who informed her that the baby was not breathing.
Kubiseski described Buth as being “frantic,” recalling her pacing in the kitchen and crying.
He transported her to the emergency department of Queensway Carleton Hospital, where the infant was pronounced dead around 5:15 a.m.
Kubiseski mentioned that Buth attempted to perform chest compressions and breaths while rubbing the baby’s limbs.
“I advised her that it would be best to lay him down,” he said, becoming emotional on the witness stand. “But I allowed her to have that time with her child.”
Buth also exhibited visible emotion in court on Tuesday, crying throughout the proceedings. Her defense attorney, Natasha Calvinho, provided her with a box of tissues during Kubiseski’s testimony.
Const. Blonde was the next to take the stand. He stated that upon entering the residence, he observed O’Connor performing CPR on the infant, who was lying on the living room floor.
Blonde took over the procedure, instructing O’Connor to continue giving breaths while he conducted chest compressions, but noted that “the child was cold to the touch.”
Blonde also recalled seeing injuries on the child’s body and hearing screams and cries during his time at the scene, although he could not identify who was making the sounds.
Both officers confirmed that the baby had no pulse.
The trial is set to continue on Wednesday and is expected to last for eight weeks.
Tag: rewrite-pending