A Quebec-based environmental legal organization, along with eight citizens, is suing the provincial government over its choice to postpone a greenhouse gas emissions reduction target by five years.
The Centre québécois du droit de l’environnement declared on Wednesday that it has submitted an application for judicial review to the Quebec Superior Court, aiming to reverse a decision that extended the deadline for achieving a 37.5 percent reduction in emissions from 1990 levels from 2030 to 2035. The plaintiffs contend that this decision breaches environmental laws and undermines their fundamental rights.
This legal challenge addresses an order-in-council that was enacted in January by the previous Coalition Avenir Québec government. The application requests that the court invalidate this decision and compel the government to reevaluate its climate targets, aligning them with its legal and constitutional responsibilities.
The plaintiffs characterize their legal action regarding the provincial climate change mitigation objectives as unprecedented in its challenge against the Quebec government.
“We assert that Quebec cannot retreat, and that the order-in-council from the previous administration is not in compliance with the law and infringes on the fundamental rights of Quebec residents,” stated executive director Geneviève Paul during a press conference at the provincial legislature.
“The new government has inherited this setback, but it also has the chance to rectify the issue.”
The office of Quebec’s newly appointed Environment Minister Jean Pellerin, who is presently at the United Nations COP31 climate conference in Turkey, issued a statement confirming that his department will thoroughly examine the legal filing.
“This lawsuit pertains to an action initiated by the prior government,” the statement noted.
Group Claims CAQ Decision Violates Charter Rights
The plaintiffs argue that the decision contravenes Quebec’s Environment Quality Act, is not in alignment with the province’s commitments under the Paris climate agreement, and violates rights safeguarded by both the Canadian and Quebec charters.
According to Quebec’s environmental regulations, the government must factor in scientific knowledge, as well as the economic, social, and environmental ramifications of climate change, alongside its international commitments when establishing emissions targets.
The plaintiffs further assert that the postponement contradicts the Paris Agreement’s principle of progression, which advocates for increasingly ambitious climate goals over time. Quebec committed to adhering to the agreement in 2016 within the scope of provincial jurisdiction.
In January, the then-environment minister Bernard Drainville announced the decision to delay the climate target, despite pushback from the province’s advisory committee on climate change, a group created to provide guidance to the government.
Drainville cited economic uncertainties and tariffs from the U.S., mentioning that several economic allies, including the United States, Ontario, and British Columbia, had reduced their climate commitments.
However, the environmental law group contends that these economic justifications lacked supporting evidence and did not adequately consider the escalating costs associated with inaction on climate change.
The group’s attorneys also argue that postponing emissions reductions heightens risks to individuals’ lives and safety, thereby violating fundamental rights protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Quebec’s Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms.
The eight individual plaintiffs hail from various regions of Quebec and include students, an agricultural entrepreneur, a social worker, and a retired municipal manager.
“The science remains unchanged, so why should our targets change?” questioned 16-year-old Flavie Léveillé, a high school student from Longueuil, a suburb of Montreal, during Wednesday’s press event.
“We can never be certain we will achieve our targets, but without ambitious, science-driven goals, progress becomes even less achievable.”
In a statement released with the lawsuit, Léveillé expressed her concerns about the world that future generations will face. “I hope to have children someday, but I cannot do so with a clear conscience if I do nothing to ensure they have a future,” she remarked.
Plaintiff Claims Climate Change Impacting Daily Life
Sylvie Beauregard, a retired municipal manager from Bedford, a town southeast of Montreal near the U.S. border, shared that climate change is already influencing her daily life.
The mother of three and grandmother of eight highlighted issues such as droughts leading to increased grocery costs, wildfires impacting her grandson who suffers from asthma, the proliferation of ticks that carry Lyme disease, and frequent hailstorms threatening local vineyards.
“We can no longer delay our fight against climate change, as our children and my grandchildren will bear the consequences,” Beauregard emphasized. “My generation has harmed the environment. We have a responsibility to mend the damage.”
The lawsuit emerges as Quebec’s new Parti Québécois government has articulated its climate goals without specifying an emissions reduction target for 2030.
During the provincial election campaign, the sovereigntist party promised to set interim targets for 2030, 2035, 2040, and 2045 as part of a strategy to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050.
The party has pledged to reduce emissions by 42.5 percent below 1990 levels by 2034.