Manitoba’s MAID Denial Rates Soar: 32% Say No to End-of-Life Aid

Marion Penner wishes for death.

“I spend my days in bed without doing anything, questioning why I am still alive,” stated Penner, who marked her 94th birthday at Steinbach’s Bethesda Regional Health Centre after a fall at her residence in December resulted in a broken pelvis.

Bedridden since then, Penner also contends with chronic heart and kidney ailments.

“What’s the purpose of existing just to rely on pain medication?” Penner remarked, as family photos adorned the windowsill of her hospital room.

Consequently, she sought medically assisted dying (MAID).

In a correspondence to Shared Health, Dr. Monty Singh from Steinbach expressed that he believed her conditions were both serious and incurable, which are prerequisites for MAID eligibility.

However, Penner reports that she was swiftly told by BRHC doctors, and by a nurse from Shared Health over the phone, that she did not meet the criteria because she was deemed too healthy.

She is not the only one in this situation.

photo collage

Marion Penner’s family photo: a collage created by one of her mentally and physically disabled sons at their Steinbach care facility. (Christopher Gareau/CBC)

Higher denial rates

Individuals in Manitoba face a significantly greater likelihood of being denied MAID eligibility compared to other regions in Canada.

The province recorded a denial rate of 32 percent in 2024, which is more than five times the national average of six percent, as per the annual federal report on MAID released in November.

This average does not account for the territories, P.E.I., New Brunswick, or Nova Scotia, as their small data sets were withheld to protect privacy.

In 2024, Manitoba’s MAID assessors turned down 175 out of 548 applications, only three fewer than Ontario, a province over ten times larger, which had 6,000 applications.

The office of Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara indicated via email that the figures for 2024 might be an outlier.

“In smaller provinces like Manitoba, even a minor fluctuation in the annual number of requests deemed ineligible can seem more pronounced when viewed as a percentage,” a spokesperson for Asagwara noted.

Manitoba’s unique situation

Nevertheless, this issue has persisted beyond just one year, and the reasons remain unclear.

Statistics from Shared Health revealed that the MAID eligibility rate fell to 26 percent in 2025, still over four times the previous year’s national average.

Manitoba stands out as the sole province with fewer MAID provisions in 2024 (186) compared to 2021 (245).

According to annual federal reports, Manitoba has recorded fewer MAID deaths than the smaller provinces of Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick since 2022, a year in which Manitoba was the only province to see its proportion of total MAID deaths relative to total deaths decrease (1.8 percent).

In contrast, the rest of Canada has seen a rise in MAID applications and acceptances since individuals with chronic conditions like Penner’s became eligible in 2021 under what is termed Track 2.

Legislation

Medical form

A diagnosis of Marion Penner sent to Shared Health. (Submitted)

The law stipulates that to qualify for MAID, patients must:

  • Have a serious and incurable illness, disease, or disability (excluding mental illness until March 17, 2027).
  • Be in an advanced state of irreversible decline in capability.
  • Experience enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be alleviated under conditions the individual deems acceptable.

Previously, death had to be “reasonably foreseeable.”

Currently, the two practitioners evaluating each Track 2 application must either possess expertise in the medical issue causing the person’s distress or consult a practitioner who does.

Unless an individual is on the verge of losing their ability to make their own healthcare decisions, Penner’s timeframe of about a month would be deemed too hasty for a Track 2 patient.

Stefanie Green, a physician affiliated with the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers, stated, “The law necessitates a minimum of 90 days to facilitate the required processes.”

Family concerns

Woman in grey sweater gesturing

Valerie Penner, Marion’s daughter, has been frustrated trying to navigate the Manitoba health-care system and MAID. (Christopher Gareau/CBC)

Valerie Penner, Marion’s daughter, expressed her frustrations with the process since she hurried to her mother’s side in December from her home in Minnesota.

She believed that family members had gathered to bid farewell when doctors conveyed their doubts about her mother surviving the broken pelvis for much longer.

She is against the idea of her mother being transferred to palliative care outside of Steinbach, the only home she has ever known.

“Especially now that she is in palliative care—implying she will pass away soon—it feels like the system merely wants to keep you until you do, so as not to impact MAID statistics,” Valerie Penner commented.

Penner is contemplating requesting a second opinion.

To do so, she would require assistance from Shared Health to connect her with two additional doctors or nurse practitioner MAID assessors among the 20 available in the province, three of whom are located in rural areas.

Awaiting her fate

Three photos of a man and woman, and children in black and white

Photos in Marion Penner’s home of herself and her late husband George Penner in different eras of their lives. (Christopher Gareau/CBC)

As Penner awaits news on whether she will be referred to another community for palliative care, she reflects on past moments when she played piano for fellow seniors, occasionally starting the festivities with an Elvis song.

She also has the opportunity to share fond memories of her late husband, George Penner, a former councillor in Steinbach and a developer pivotal to the city’s expansion.

When asked how she wishes to be remembered, Penner humbly stated that while others may have more eloquent phrases, her own are straightforward: “She did her best.”

WATCH | Manitobans denied MAID more often than other Canadians:

Manitobans denied MAID more often than other Canadians

March 10|

Duration

3:12

A Steinbach woman was denied medical assistance in dying and does not know why. In Manitoba, people are deemed ineligible for MAID at a much higher rate than anywhere else in Canada.

Tag: rewrite-pending

Source

Latest

MP Berthold Fights for Change After Son’s Tragic Battle with Addiction

WARNING: This story contains details about suicide.At their kitchen...

From Humble Beginnings to Billions: GTA VI Breaks Sales Records

During the development of the initial Grand Theft Auto...

Carney Critiques Putin Amid APEC Talks, Stresses Need for Sanctions

During the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China,...

Gas Prices Drop Nationwide: Canada Sees Relief at the Pump

No, you're not imagining things — gas prices are...

Don't miss

MP Berthold Fights for Change After Son’s Tragic Battle with Addiction

WARNING: This story contains details about suicide.At their kitchen...

From Humble Beginnings to Billions: GTA VI Breaks Sales Records

During the development of the initial Grand Theft Auto...

Carney Critiques Putin Amid APEC Talks, Stresses Need for Sanctions

During the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China,...

Gas Prices Drop Nationwide: Canada Sees Relief at the Pump

No, you're not imagining things — gas prices are...

Young Activist Inspires High Schoolers at Sustainability Conference

Quinn MacAskill has been actively involved in climate advocacy...

MP Berthold Fights for Change After Son’s Tragic Battle with Addiction

WARNING: This story contains details about suicide.At their kitchen table, Luc and Caro gaze at each other while clasping hands firmly. They experienced the...

From Humble Beginnings to Billions: GTA VI Breaks Sales Records

During the development of the initial Grand Theft Auto in the 1990s, Brian Baglow had no foresight into the monumental series it would eventually...

Carney Critiques Putin Amid APEC Talks, Stresses Need for Sanctions

During the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China, Prime Minister Mark Carney criticized Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine, even as Russian President Vladimir...