A lively audience of comedy enthusiasts was treated to a show on Tuesday night at a Toronto theatre, where numerous Nathan Fielder impersonators aimed to answer a quirky question: Who bears the closest resemblance to Nathan Fielder?
Thirty participants donned grey wigs for this competition celebrating the Canadian comedian and filmmaker known for his uniquely sincere demeanor, recognized for his docu-comedies Nathan for You, The Rehearsal, and the latest documentary sensation You Can See Everything.
Competitors embraced the challenge with costumes that included headphones and button-down shirts, while others mimicked Fielder’s characteristic vacant expression and deadpan humor.
However, looking like Fielder was just one aspect of the event. Throughout the night at the Paradise Theatre, contestants tackled a business pitch challenge, engaged in a staring contest, and concluded with a dialogue with a version of Elizabeth Holmes, the fallen tech executive featured in You Can See Everything, brought to life by Second City veteran Hannah Spear.
The pitch segment yielded ideas reminiscent of Nathan For You, where Fielder portrays an awkward business consultant presenting outrageous marketing strategies to assist struggling businesses. One contestant, David, a drummer, proposed a plan to expand his indie band’s Instagram following without spending on advertisements, claiming they had 250 followers, “of which 40 are my mom’s friends,” before displaying a QR code to connect with the band.
Another contestant suggested a celebrity lookalike competition where winners would pay instead of receiving cash prizes. “This is not a prize list. This is a price list,” quipped one of the participants.
Andrew Phung, known for his work in Kim’s Convenience and Run the Burbs, opened the event with a grand welcome, referring to Fielder as “a cultural icon, a Canadian pop culture sensation, and a graduate of one of Canada’s leading business schools with excellent grades” — a humorous nod to the introduction of Nathan for You and Fielder’s actual business degree from the University of Victoria, which he obtained in 2005.
Phung and Spear evaluated the contestants alongside Kelly White and Megan Bianco, hosts of the Nathan for Us fan podcast.

Thirty contestants and fans of awkward comedy filled the Paradise Theatre on Tuesday. (Christine Pagulayan/CBC)
The judges shortlisted three finalists, assessing their looks, costumes, physical presence, business pitches, and improvisational abilities. Jayden Williams from Toronto emerged victorious by maintaining his character throughout the event.
“There were some strong Nathan contenders,” Daniels shared with CBC News. “I’m both surprised and honored to have won.”
Daniels mentioned that friends had persistently sent him the event flyer, prompting him to finally participate. He also had a winning track record, having claimed victory in two Halloween costume contests as Fielder.
When asked about his ability to stay in character, Daniels paused and deflected with a response fitting of the comedian he was emulating: “I really, I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

Daniels, center, mentioned that he had previously won two Halloween contests dressed as Fielder. (Lucky Osunbiyi Photography)
The event drew both dedicated fans and newcomers who had recently discovered Fielder’s work. Some were captivated by his deadpan humor, while others appreciated the unsettling nature of his comedy.
“He gives me chills, and that’s why I enjoy him,” one audience member remarked. The fan added that Fielder seems “like an alien on Earth trying to blend in with humans.”
Another admirer described him as “Canadian excellence,” noting that his earlier work has gained a broader audience as his fame has grown.
Following the announcement of the winner, the audience settled in for a viewing of the first episode of The Curse, Fielder’s collaboration with Benny Safdie.
-
Loved You Can See Everything? Thank Canada
-
REVIEW
Nathan Fielder’s You Can See Everything gazes into the abyss of Elizabeth Holmes
The lookalike contest took place amid a resurgence of interest in Fielder’s projects, including You Can See Everything, the acclaimed documentary co-directed with Lance Oppenheim that explores the story of Elizabeth Holmes, the disgraced founder of Theranos. Attendees at the theatre said the film either introduced them to Fielder or rekindled their enthusiasm for his work.
Fielder lookalike competitions have also been held in cities such as New York, Los Angeles, and Sydney. However, for one evening, Toronto’s many Nathans shared the spotlight, with one taking home the title of “the Nathanest Nathan,” as dubbed by social media users.
Daniels expressed a desire to see more lookalike events in other Canadian cities like Montreal and Hamilton. “But it was great to have one in Toronto, featuring one of Canada’s icons,” he stated.