On Tuesday, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre sharply criticized the Liberal government’s management of relations between Canada and the U.S., asserting that the outcomes have not met expectations and that the prime minister is “losing” the trade conflict.
After Prime Minister Mark Carney introduced his new trade advisory council aimed at addressing the U.S. dispute — which features several prominent Conservatives — Poilievre expressed his discontent, emphasizing that the Liberals campaigned on resolving the issue in the previous election, yet no significant advancements have been made.
“What has Mark Carney accomplished in a year regarding this? He hasn’t engaged in negotiations for five months. The only discussions Carney is conducting are YouTube videos where he likens himself to Sir Isaac Brock,” Poilievre mocked, ridiculing Carney for referencing the War of 1812 hero who lost his life defending what is now Canada from a past American invasion.
This also refers to Pete Hoekstra, the U.S. ambassador to Canada, who mentioned that there have been no “substantive” trade discussions between the two nations since President Donald Trump reacted last autumn to an Ontario advertisement featuring former president Ronald Reagan criticizing tariffs.
The U.S. has had two meetings with Mexico this year concerning the upcoming CUSMA review — with a deadline of July 1 to determine whether to extend the trilateral agreement for another 16 years — yet no date has been arranged for discussions with Canada.
Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc informed MPs late last week that dialogues with the Trump administration continue, but achieving a mutually advantageous agreement has proved to be a “challenge.”
LeBlanc also emphasized that Canada is not seeking a “one-off” trade agreement with the U.S., but is aiming for a “broader” understanding encompassing economic and other matters.
Canada is advocating for Trump to eliminate his stringent tariffs on steel, aluminum, automobiles, and lumber, but he has not done so. In contrast, the U.S. is insisting that Canada modify its dairy access regulations and lift certain protections for its cultural sector, among other requests.
“He was elected with the singular promise of negotiating a win with the U.S., and since then he’s been losing, losing, losing,” Poilievre remarked about Carney.
Some U.S. tariffs on Canadian products, particularly lumber and certain steel-based items, have actually risen over the past year, Poilievre pointed out. “Another disastrous failure for someone who claims to be a master negotiator,” he stated.
Poilievre’s personal criticism on Tuesday follows his earlier remarks last week where he described Carney, the Oxford-educated former central banker in both Canada and the U.K., as “poorly educated in economics.”
While Carney has indicated that there has been a “rupture” in the bilateral relationship due to the protectionist policies of Trump, Poilievre has called for strengthening ties with the U.S. to alleviate these economic tensions.
Poilievre has suggested reviving the auto pact and providing Americans with preferential access to Canada’s critical minerals. The Conservative leader is also advocating for increased oil and gas exports to the U.S., a move he believes could persuade Trump to reach an agreement.
“A serious prime minister, after a year into this conflict, should be able to articulate his plan. I have shared my plan with you,” Poilievre stated.
In a recent address to business leaders in Toronto, Poilievre argued that Carney is mistaken in believing that a permanent divide with the U.S., Canada’s largest trading partner, is feasible.
“We require a tariff-free agreement. We must eliminate these barriers,” the leader asserted.
A representative for LeBlanc informed CBC News that the minister, Canada’s ambassador to the U.S., Mark Wiseman, and Janice Charette, Canada’s chief negotiator, are “continuously engaging with their U.S. counterparts.”
“Canada is ready. We have put forth several proposals to the Americans. We are prepared to work swiftly towards a deal and will certainly not be the cause of any delay,” the spokesperson stated.

